Tag Archives: John Jay

A John Jay Papers milestone on President’s Day

We’re celebrating the release of volume five of The Selected Papers of John Jay1788-1794 (Charlottesville and London: University of Virginia Press, 2017).

Jay Papers editor Robb Haberman says, “It opens with the ratification of the Constitution, and covers Jay’s role in the forming of the new government as acting Secretary of State prior to Jefferson’s taking office and as first Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.”

Also explored are his gubernatorial campaign of 1792, the Genet Affair, and the events leading to the negotiation of the Jay Treaty with Great Britain.

In our six degrees of separation game, speaking of George Washington and President’s Day, pop over to the Papers of George Washington Newsletter to Robb’s article on the friendship between Jay and Washington. It’s a bromance “forged in war” and a lot more apt for the day than buying a mattress.

Loaded Dice

Currently on view in the Rare Book and Manuscript Library is a small but fascinating exhibition of dice, from the Smith Collection of Mathematical  Instruments. They date from the Roman era to the early 20th century. David Eugene Smith (1860-1944) was a professor of mathematics at Teachers College, Columbia University. He used these dice in his lectures, to show the “development of one of the oldest numbers games known.” Smith’s collection of mathematical instruments, manuscripts, and books is in the RBML, and was the subject of an exhibition in 2002-2003.

I was particularly excited by this exhibition, not only because of my personal interest in the history of gambling, but because (believe it or not) of something in the John Jay Papers.

In 1794, John Jay, then serving as Chief Supreme Court Justice, was appointed by Washington to serve as Envoy Extraordinary to negotiate a treaty concerning the general commerce between the said United States and the British Empire, and also to address certain unexecuted or ignored aspects of the 1783 Peace Treaty.  His eldest son, Peter Augustus, then 18, accompanied his father. He had just graduated from Columbia College, and his mother, Sarah, thought the London trip would be a grand opportunity for him. His father had misgivings, but eventually agreed. During their residence in London, Peter kept a diary in four notebooks, in which he recorded the sights and people they encountered. Among the people he met were the artist Benjamin West, philosopher Jeremy Bentham, Prime Minister William Pitt the younger, and manufacturer Josiah Wedgewood. He attended the theater, seeing Mrs. Siddons perform numerous times, grand balls and assemblies, and visited galleries, libraries, and museums. It was at the British Museum that he encountered a pair of loaded dice.


Monday 23rd. June [1794] I breakfasted this morning with Mr. Paradise, who was so obliging as afterwards to attend me to the British Museum– This edifice is a fine one, & it contains such numbers & variety that in one morning, it is impossible to gain much more than a knoledge of their disposition . . . We saw in another room a number of Roman dice, some of which appear to have been loaded, many Play & Lottery Tickets consisting principally of figures cut from ivory

Peter Augustus’s diaries, located in the John Jay Papers collection at RBML, were probably kept both to hone Peter’s observatory and writing skills, serve as a souvenir, and to share with his family and friends back home. They provide a unique window on Jay’s negotiation, as they list where and with whom the father and son visited. The Jay collection also contains many letters, both official and private, from the mission, as well as Jay’s letter book and account book.

(However, it’s not clear if any of the dice in the exhibition are loaded.)

John Jay’s Circuit Court Diary

"Your Letter by the Miss Allens is the last that I have recd— I ought to have seen those Ladies, but the Court has unceasingly engrossed my Time– we did not adjourn until 9 last Night– I feel fatigued in body and mind; but Reflections of this kind are not to be endulged– . . . I am very anxious to be with you, and the moment the preparatory measures here will permit, I shall set out–" April 19 1794 John Jay to Sarah Livingston Jay

While many people know that John Jay was the first Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, most do not know that during his tenure, the Justices were required to "ride circuit" or preside over cases in the circuit courts of the various federal judicial districts. The arduousness of this task can be seen in the many letters between Jay and his family and friends during this period, and vividly in the diary he kept between April 1790 and August 1792.

John Jay's Circuit Court diary is a small, worn, leather-bound notebook, housed now in a custom case for protection. In tiny script, Jay recorded not only the cases he presided over, but the miles he journeyed, the people he met, and the places he stayed. Jay provides a veritable Baedeker of the inns and taverns of the Eastern Circuit, commenting (sometimes not so favorably) on the food, entertainment, and beds. Throughout, he shows a keen interest in the state of the country, the development of political and social institutions, the sentiments of the inhabitants, and the progress of agriculture and industry, as well as recording interesting bits of gossip and unusual stories.

However, Jay's legendary prudence sometimes leaves the reader unsatisfied. For example, on May 25 1790, he wrote "Dined with Mr. Barretts– His Gardens are pretty– his House in order– Entertains well– heard many anecdotes, not to be written–"

The diary, much of Jay's correspondence of this time, and drafts of his charges to the Grand Juries of the Eastern Circuit may be found in the John Jay Papers collection, located in the Rare Book and Manuscript Library. Scans of many of the documents, including the diary, may be viewed in the digital archive, The Papers of John Jay.  The Circuit Court diary will be published in volume 5 of The Selected Papers of John Jay.